AHAs explained: glycolic, lactic and mandelic acid, the 10% and pH 3.5 line, and the sunburn alert

Alpha hydroxy acids, usually shortened to AHAs, are the ingredients behind most "glow" toners, resurfacing serums and overnight peels. They are among the best-studied exfoliants in cosmetics, and also among the easiest to overuse. Knowing which acid you are buying, how strong the product really is, and why American labels warn about the sun makes the difference between smoother skin and a stinging, flaky week.
- AHAs are water-soluble acids that loosen dead cells on the surface of the skin. The most common in cosmetics are glycolic and lactic acid.
- Strength depends on both the percentage and the pH. The safety conditions behind most consumer products are an AHA concentration of 10 percent or less and a final pH of 3.5 or higher.
- AHAs make skin more sensitive to UV while you use them and for about a week afterwards, which is why the FDA recommends a "Sunburn Alert" on the label.
- Start two or three evenings a week, never in the same routine as other exfoliants, and wear sunscreen every morning.
What an AHA does on the skin
The outermost layer of skin, the stratum corneum, is made of flattened dead cells held together by a kind of mortar. Normally those cells shed invisibly. When they linger, skin looks dull, feels rough and can look uneven in tone. AHAs are small, polar molecules that weaken the bonds holding these cells together, so they come away more evenly. A 2018 review by Sheau-Chung Tang and Jen-Hung Yang in the journal Molecules describes this loosening of cell cohesion as the main way AHAs work, and lists the factors that decide how far it goes: concentration, pH, how long the product stays on the skin, and how much of the acid is in its free, active form.
Because they dissolve in water rather than oil, AHAs work mostly on the surface. That is the key difference from salicylic acid, which mixes with sebum and works inside pores. If blackheads are your main problem, our guide to salicylic acid is the better place to start; if your concern is texture, dullness or dry, rough patches, an AHA is usually the better fit.
Glycolic, lactic, mandelic: how they differ
All AHAs share the same basic chemistry, but the size of the molecule and its other properties change how a product feels.
| Acid (INCI name) | What sets it apart | Often suits |
|---|---|---|
| Glycolic acid | The smallest AHA, with only two carbon atoms. It tends to act quickly and is the acid most likely to sting. | Normal, oily or sun-damaged skin that already tolerates exfoliants |
| Lactic acid | A slightly larger molecule. Its salt, sodium lactate, is part of the skin's own natural moisturizing factor, so it is often chosen for drier skin. | Dry, rough or first-time users |
| Mandelic acid | Much larger, with a benzene ring; its name comes from the German word for almond. Usually described as slower and gentler. | Sensitive skin, or skin that marks easily after irritation |
| Citric and malic acid | Often present at low levels to adjust the pH of a formula rather than to exfoliate. | Read as a pH adjuster unless the brand says otherwise |
You will also see polyhydroxy acids such as gluconolactone, marketed as a gentler cousin of the AHAs. They are larger again and are generally positioned for sensitive skin; the evidence base for them is smaller than for glycolic and lactic acid. In practice, the formula as a whole matters more than the name of the acid: a well-buffered 8 percent glycolic lotion can be easier to live with than a harsh 5 percent toner.
Why the percentage is only half the story
An acid exfoliates when it is in its free, unneutralized form, and how much of it is free depends on the pH of the product. The lower the pH, the more free acid and the stronger the effect, but also the greater the risk of stinging and irritation. That is why two products both labelled "10% glycolic" can behave very differently on the skin.
The FDA summarises the conclusion of the Cosmetic Ingredient Review, the industry-funded expert panel that assesses cosmetic ingredients in the US. It found glycolic and lactic acid products safe for consumers when three conditions are met: the AHA concentration is 10 percent or less; the final product has a pH of 3.5 or greater; and the product either protects the skin from increased sun sensitivity or its directions tell you to use sun protection every day. Products used only by professionals, such as salon peels, fall outside these consumer conditions and should stay in professional hands.
Most brands do not print the pH on the bottle, and US cosmetic labels list ingredients by name, not by percentage. When a brand does state a percentage, check whether it refers to the acid itself or to a blend. Our guide to reading an INCI list explains how to estimate where an acid sits in a formula from its position on the list.
The sunburn alert, and the study behind it
AHAs are the reason some American products carry a printed warning about the sun. Research carried out by the FDA found that after four weeks of applying AHA products, volunteers' sensitivity to UV-induced reddening rose by 18 percent, and the sensitivity of their skin cells to UV damage doubled on average. The effect was reversible: one week after the volunteers stopped, the researchers found no significant difference in UV sensitivity between treated and untreated skin.
On the strength of that work, the FDA recommends this text on cosmetics containing AHAs: "Sunburn Alert: This product contains an alpha hydroxy acid (AHA) that may increase your skin's sensitivity to the sun and particularly the possibility of sunburn. Use a sunscreen, wear protective clothing, and limit sun exposure while using this product and for a week afterwards." It is guidance rather than a legal requirement, so not every label carries it, and products made for other markets may not mention it at all. The advice applies regardless of what the label says. Our article on how much sunscreen to use covers the quantity most people underestimate.
Who does well with AHAs, and who should go carefully
- Dry, rough skin. Often responds well, especially to lactic acid followed by a rich moisturizer.
- Normal or oily skin with dull texture. Glycolic acid is the classic choice; oily skin with clogged pores may benefit from alternating it with salicylic acid on different nights.
- Sensitive skin, rosacea or eczema. Acids can sting and trigger flares. Patch test first, choose mandelic acid or a low-strength lactic acid, or skip AHAs entirely.
- Darker skin tones. Irritation can leave dark marks that last longer than the irritation itself. A slow start matters more than the choice of acid.
- Already using a prescription retinoid or acne treatment. Ask the prescriber before adding an acid; the combination is a common cause of raw, peeling skin.
Normal reactions are a brief tingle and, in the first weeks, some dryness. Burning that lasts, redness that does not fade within an hour, or patches of shiny, tight skin are signs to stop for a week and return less often, if at all.
Adding an AHA to your routine
- Pick one product. A leave-on toner, serum or lotion; a rinse-off cleanser is gentler but does less.
- Use it in the evening, on clean, dry skin, two or three times a week for the first month. Keep it away from the eyes and the corners of the nose and mouth.
- Follow with a plain moisturizer. If your skin feels tight, a moisturizer with glycerin or ceramides helps.
- Keep other exfoliants on other nights. Do not layer an AHA with salicylic acid, a retinoid, benzoyl peroxide or a scrub in the same routine. Our guide to combining active ingredients has a weekly schedule that alternates them.
- Wear sunscreen every morning, and keep doing so for a week after you stop.
- Judge after six to eight weeks. Skin turnover is gradual. If you see no change, a different acid is a better next step than a stronger one.
In a hot, humid climate, where sweat and sunscreen already sit on the skin all day, a lightweight lactic or mandelic serum a few nights a week is often enough. Daily strong acids are rarely necessary for anyone, and the most common mistake with AHAs is not choosing the wrong one, but using too much, too often.
Sources
- US Food and Drug Administration, "Alpha Hydroxy Acids", cosmetic ingredient information page (CIR safety conditions, UV sensitivity research, recommended Sunburn Alert labeling).
- Tang S.-C., Yang J.-H., "Dual Effects of Alpha-Hydroxy Acids on the Skin", Molecules, 23(4):863, 2018.
- US Food and Drug Administration, Guidance for Industry: Labeling for Topically Applied Cosmetic Products Containing Alpha Hydroxy Acids as Ingredients, 2005.
IngredientsSalicylic acid explained
Why an oil-soluble acid suits blackheads, the 0.5 to 2% range on US acne labels, cleansers versus leave-ons, and the cases where it needs caution.
IngredientsCombining active ingredients
Retinoids, acids, vitamin C, niacinamide and benzoyl peroxide: a pairing table and a simple weekly plan.
US and Asian skincareHow much sunscreen to use
Half a teaspoon for the face, a shot glass for the body, every two hours: the numbers behind the advice.